Most businesses assume that if they pay VAT to a supplier, they can reclaim it. But if that supplier turns out to be part of a VAT fraud, HMRC can refuse your claim, even if you did nothing wrong yourself.
How VAT fraud works
In missing trader and carousel fraud, a business charges VAT on its sales and then disappears without paying it to HMRC. The goods often pass through several companies, sometimes across borders, so the fraud can sit anywhere in the chain. Electronics, mobile phones and other high-value, fast-moving goods are common targets.
The ‘knew or should have known’ test
Under long-established case law, HMRC can deny input VAT if a business knew, or should have known, that its purchase was connected with fraud. You do not need to have taken part. If the warning signs were there and you did not check, you can still lose the VAT.
Warning signs to look out for
- A newly formed supplier offering large volumes at prices below market
- A VAT number that is invalid, recently cancelled or registered to a different name or address
- No real trading address, website or history
- Frequent changes of directors or ownership
- Requests to pay third parties or to change bank details at short notice
What reasonable checks look like
Before trading, confirm the supplier’s VAT number is valid and registered to the same name and address. Check the company is real and active, who its directors and owners are, and whether its website supports the business it claims to run. Keep a dated record of every check. After onboarding, keep checking: a VAT number that was valid in January may be cancelled by June.
How AI Verify 360 helps
AI Verify 360 validates VAT and EORI numbers, verifies the company and its directors, screens for sanctions and anti-money laundering (AML) risks, and monitors every company daily for changes, including VAT registration. Each check is time-stamped, giving you evidence that you took reasonable care. No tool can guarantee a supplier is genuine, but consistent, recorded checks make it much harder to argue you should have known.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. See how AI Verify 360 helps businesses verify and monitor the companies they work with at verify360.ai.